Communication of Hospital-to-Home Transition Information for Pediatric Patients of Parents/Caregivers with Limited English Proficiency or Health Literacy Deficit: An Integrative Review

Research Article

J Pediatr & Child Health Care. 2024; 9(1): 1062.

Communication of Hospital-to-Home Transition Information for Pediatric Patients of Parents/Caregivers with Limited English Proficiency or Health Literacy Deficit: An Integrative Review

Huaqiong Zhou1,2; Pamela A Roberts1; Melisa J Young1; Phillip R Della1*

1Curtin School of Nursing, Curtin University, Western Australia, GPO Box U1987, Perth, Western Australia

2Perth Children’s Hospital, 15 Hospital Avenue, Nedlands, Western Australia

*Corresponding author: Phillip R Della Professor John Curtin Distinguished Emeritus, Curtin School of Nursing, Curtin University, Western Australia, GPO Box U1987, Perth, Western Australia. Email: p.della@curtin.edu.au

Received: December 28, 2023 Accepted: February 01, 2024 Published: February 07, 2024

Abstract

Purpose: To comprehensively review the research evidence on communicating hospital-to-home transition information for pediatric patients of parents/caregivers with limited English proficiency or health literacy deficit.

Design and Methods: An integrative review was conducted following the 5-stage framework. Medline, CINAHL, and Embase (Ovid) were searched from 2013 to 30th November 2023. Key search terms included ‘child/infant/adolescent/pediatric’, ‘limited English proficiency/health literacy’, ‘discharge/transition/continuity of care’, ‘communication’.

Results: Thirty-five studies met the selection criteria. Caregivers with limited language proficiency ranged from 6.9% to 60.2% and 8% to 55% had a deficit in health literacy. These families tend to have lower social-economic status. Caregivers were generally given inconsistent and incomplete verbal transition information. Only one-third of caregivers received translated written information of their preferred language and half of healthcare providers often used professional interpreters. Children of caregivers with language barriers were at significantly higher risk of medication errors, unplanned ED returned visits, and readmissions. Professional interpretation and translation of transition information are evidently improving caregivers’ comprehension and satisfaction.

Conclusion: The finding affirmed the unique challenges when communicating hospital-to-home transition information with caregivers with limited English proficiency or health literacy deficits. Inconsistent and incomplete transitioning care information with inappropriate levels of health literacy led to overwhelmingly negative patient adverse health outcomes.

Practice Implications: To ensure caregivers accessing transition care information, it is recommended to provide professional translated written information and interpreter service. Transition information should also be prepared with an appropriate level of health literacy and a teach-back technique to be used to confirm caregivers’ comprehension.

Keywords: Communication; Hospital-to-home transition information; Pediatric patients; Caregivers with limited English proficiency or health literacy deficit

Introduction

The discharge planning process is critical to ensure a successful transition from care in the hospital to home. The transition can induce stress, especially when the person has complex needs, which require extensive preparation to enable continuity of care for a safe and successful recovery to avoid unplanned Emergency Department (ED) return visits or rehospitalization. Transitioning from hospital-to-home requires planning, education, and coordination that is deeply reliant on communication between the multidisciplinary team and the patient and family/caregiver [1].

The transition of children from hospital to home presents unique challenges, as continuity of care is dependent on the involvement of the child’s family or caregivers. Caregivers is used throughout this paper to recognize the critical role of the people who provide continuity of care for the child at home. Cummings et al. (2010) [2] recommend that rather than considering referral and discharge as a singular event, the transition from hospital to home requires processes that extend beyond the health care service. This requires accurate, legible, and relevant transitioning information to be communicated with the patient, caregivers, and ongoing health service supports. Key transitioning information includes discharge medications, follow-up appointments, return precautions and seeking medical advice associated with discharge diagnoses [3].

The World Health Organisation (WHO) identifies the importance of communication to protect the health of individuals and families/caregivers. It reflects this in the principles for effective communication: accessible, relevant, timely, actionable, credible, and understandable messages. The United States Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) identifies communication problems as the most frequent root cause of serious adverse events reported to the Sentinel Event Database, thereby recognising the critical role communication plays in the safe delivery of healthcare [4]. Likewise, the Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care [5] recognises transition points of care as one of three high-risk areas where communication is critical to patient safety, by reducing the risks associated with medication management, ongoing care, and readmission. Enhancing a patient’s knowledge of their condition and treatment can help to ensure a safe transition at the end of a hospital stay.

A meta-analysis conducted by Hamline et al. (2018) [6] included 71 articles that examined a wide variety of discharge interventions. These interventions were grouped as provider communication (i.e., discharge letters), care coordination (i.e. pre-specified discharge criteria and post-discharge follow-up), and family/caregiver engagement (education and demonstration). The analysis found that most interventions improved parental satisfaction, and there was strong evidence that pooling of interventions improved outcomes. However, the effectiveness of the interventions varied according to different populations, and the outcomes were unable to be generalised [6].

According to the AHRQ [4], 8.6% of the United States population have Limited English Proficiency (LEP), which can create language barriers that significantly impact on health care and patient safety. Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) [7] reports 27.6% of the Australian population were born overseas, and the top three languages used at home other than English were Mandarin (2.7%), Arabic (1.4%), Vietnamese (1.3%) and 3.4% of Australian population speaks English not well or not all in 2021 [8]. The LEP patients have been shown to have a limited comprehension of transitioning care information, which can affect the success of the transition from a healthcare facility to home. Furthermore, AHRQ lists discharge as a high-risk scenario for communication related patient safety concerns, and advocates for greater use of interpreters at discharge [4].

In the most recent narrative review, Osorio Galeano and Salazar Maya (2023) [9] recommended that the educational process of transition to home be supported by educational material such as booklets and videos, sheets, applications, and virtual contents, to consolidate information and provide a consultative resource for caregivers and families on discharge. The authors identified the importance of education and support materials that are clear, simple, ‘friendly in presentation’, and in a language understood by caregivers, particularly regarding the warning signs that may indicate a potential deterioration. A systematic review of parental discharge information delivery conducted by Glick et al. (2017) [3] also found that using multiple modes of information delivery was more effective in reducing errors related to discharge. Although most of these studies excluded non-English speaking participants, ELP was found to be a common risk factor associated with higher rates of management errors and lower health outcomes, and only five of the studies included in the review reported assessing low health literacy. However, the published reviews were based on the general pediatric population and healthcare delivery. There is no published review of literature focusing on hospital-to-home transitions of care for pediatric patients of caregivers with LEP or health literacy.

Aim and Objectives

This paper aimed to provide a comprehensive review of research evidence on communicating hospital-to-home transition information for pediatric patients of caregivers with LEP or health literacy deficit. The objectives were to synthesise research evidence focussed on (1) the prevalence and characteristics of pediatric patients with LEP or health literacy deficit; (2) delivery of hospital-to-home transition information; (3) the impact of LEP or health literacy deficit on the transition process and the recovery experiences of patients/caregivers; and (4) effectiveness of interventions to improve transition information delivery.

Design and Methods

An integrative review was conducted to collate and synthesise evidence with diverse data collection methods [10,11]. The PRISMA statement was also used, in combination with the integrative review, to guide the review, minimise analysis bias and systematically present findings.

Search Strategy and Search Outcomes

Three electronic databases, namely Medline, CINAHL, and Embase (Ovid), were searched from 2013 to 30th November 2023. Key search terms were ‘child/infant/adolescent/pediatric’ AND ‘limited English proficiency/culturally and linguistically diverse/low health literacy/health literacy deficit’ AND ‘discharge service/program/transition/continuity of care’ AND ‘communication’. Search strategies focused on the inclusion of studies that examined the hospital-to-home transition process and recovery experience of both caregivers and pediatric patients discharged from the hospital to home either from the inpatient ward or the ED. Studies published in English with full-text access were eligible for inclusion. Studies published in peer-reviewed journals with detailed descriptions of study design and methods were also included. Conference abstracts were excluded. Studies that involved transitioning patients between healthcare institutions were excluded from this review as the focus related to discharging patients from acute healthcare services to home. Studies examining communication but not focused during the transition process and time of discharge were also excluded.

The screening process used for the initial search is illustrated in Figure 1. A total of 454 records were identified. Of those 127 duplicated records were removed leaving 327 records to be screened. A further 285 records were excluded due to irrelevance. Of the remaining 42 records, nine conference abstracts were also excluded. Full text of 33 records were retrieved and reviewed against the selection criteria, a further three studies were then excluded as two [12,13] were not focused on communication during the transition process and at the time of discharge and one [14] was conducted in China regarding health literacy. Examination of the reference lists of the remaining 30 studies identified five additional studies to be included in this literature review resulting in a total of 35 studies.

Citation: Zhou H, Roberts PA, Young MJ, Della PR. Communication of Hospital-to-Home Transition Information for Pediatric Patients of Parents/Caregivers with Limited English Proficiency or Health Literacy Deficit: An Integrative Review. J Pediatr & Child Health Care. 2024; 9(1): 1062.